For much of the modern era, the medical model has shaped how we think about mental health. It’s a useful framework, but perhaps it leaves something important out. What if some of the most powerful human experiences don’t fit neatly into the categories of illness and disorder?
A pioneering article, “Mysticism and Mental Health: A Critical Dialogue,” takes up this very question. It examines the surprising—and often overlooked—connections between mystical experiences and psychological well-being.
Research shows that mystical or spiritual experiences are more common than we might assume. Studies suggest that anywhere from 20% to 40% of people report having had one. As these findings become more widely recognized, researchers, theologians, and mental health professionals are beginning to open up a fresh dialogue.
Drawing the Line
One of the article’s key insights is the importance of distinguishing between mystical experiences and psychotic episodes. At first glance, they can look similar—both may involve altered states of consciousness and unusual perceptions. But the difference lies in the outcome:
-
Mystical experiences tend to bring greater integration and wholeness. They can spark healing, inspire meaning, and open the door to higher levels of personal growth.
-
Psychotic episodes, by contrast, often lead to fragmentation and disorientation. They are more likely to be marked by terror, fear, and disordered thought.
The article stresses that confusing a spiritual crisis with a psychotic break can be damaging. Too often, this mistake has led to the suppression of what might have been a transformative process. Recovering the insights of mystical traditions could help fill a gap in modern mental health care—offering guidance for those navigating profound experiences and supporting them toward healing and growth.
Comments