There's a video of Trump in his plane again, this time saying "Ronald Reagan loved tariffs" in response to the Ontario Government's US-broadcast ad against them. So I asked Google Gemini to assess this claim.
From what I can see, Reagan entered into the old gray zone between principle and practice.
Earthpages.org
Trump says "Ronald Reagan loved tariffs." Do you agree or disagree based on historical evidence?
Based on historical evidence, the statement that "Ronald Reagan loved tariffs" is not generally agreed upon and is contradictory to his stated principles, though his administration did use protectionist measures in practice.
Here is a breakdown of the historical evidence on Ronald Reagan's views on tariffs and trade:
1. Reagan's Stated Principle: Strong Support for Free Trade
Anti-Tariff Rhetoric: Reagan frequently and consistently spoke out against tariffs and protectionism. He often cited the disastrous Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 as a historical example of how high tariffs can worsen economic downturns and lead to trade wars.
"Loath to Take": In an April 1987 radio address, which is often quoted, Reagan explicitly said that imposing tariffs and trade barriers were steps he was "loath to take," warning that in the long run, "such trade barriers hurt every American worker and consumer."
Key Trade Agreements: His administration was a primary proponent of the U.S.-Canada Free Trade Agreement (signed in 1988), which was a precursor to the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). This demonstrates a foundational belief in opening up markets.
2. Reagan's Practice: Use of Protectionist Measures (Pragmatism)
Despite his free-trade philosophy, the Reagan administration did, at times, use tariffs and other protectionist tools, largely as a response to intense political pressure and what he deemed as "unfair" foreign trade practices:
"Voluntary Export Restraints" (VERs): He persuaded Japan to adopt "voluntary" restraints on auto exports and secured similar agreements on steel from other nations. VERs function like non-tariff quotas.
Specific Tariffs/Duties: He imposed tariffs on items like Canadian lumber and, notably, a 100% tariff on certain Japanese electronic products (semiconductors) in 1987 after alleging Japan had violated a trade agreement.
"Free and Fair Trade": Reagan often qualified his support for free trade by insisting on "fair trade," suggesting that the use of retaliatory tariffs was a pragmatic tool to force trading partners to open their markets or adhere to agreements, rather than an economic goal in itself. He framed these actions as a way to "deal with a particular problem, not begin a trade war."
Conclusion
The historical record suggests Reagan was fundamentally a free-trade advocate who viewed protectionism as self-destructive. However, as a political pragmatist facing significant domestic pressure and foreign trade challenges, he selectively used protectionist measures—including tariffs—to combat what he saw as "unfair" practices and to leverage better terms for American industries, especially during the 1980s.
Therefore, the claim that he "loved tariffs" is not accurate regarding his core economic philosophy, but it is true that his administration utilized them as a negotiating or retaliatory tool.
Here is a breakdown of the historical evidence on Ronald Reagan's views on tariffs and trade:
1. Reagan's Stated Principle: Strong Support for Free Trade
Anti-Tariff Rhetoric: Reagan frequently and consistently spoke out against tariffs and protectionism. He often cited the disastrous Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 as a historical example of how high tariffs can worsen economic downturns and lead to trade wars.
"Loath to Take": In an April 1987 radio address, which is often quoted, Reagan explicitly said that imposing tariffs and trade barriers were steps he was "loath to take," warning that in the long run, "such trade barriers hurt every American worker and consumer."
Key Trade Agreements: His administration was a primary proponent of the U.S.-Canada Free Trade Agreement (signed in 1988), which was a precursor to the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). This demonstrates a foundational belief in opening up markets.
2. Reagan's Practice: Use of Protectionist Measures (Pragmatism)
Despite his free-trade philosophy, the Reagan administration did, at times, use tariffs and other protectionist tools, largely as a response to intense political pressure and what he deemed as "unfair" foreign trade practices:
"Voluntary Export Restraints" (VERs): He persuaded Japan to adopt "voluntary" restraints on auto exports and secured similar agreements on steel from other nations. VERs function like non-tariff quotas.
Specific Tariffs/Duties: He imposed tariffs on items like Canadian lumber and, notably, a 100% tariff on certain Japanese electronic products (semiconductors) in 1987 after alleging Japan had violated a trade agreement.
"Free and Fair Trade": Reagan often qualified his support for free trade by insisting on "fair trade," suggesting that the use of retaliatory tariffs was a pragmatic tool to force trading partners to open their markets or adhere to agreements, rather than an economic goal in itself. He framed these actions as a way to "deal with a particular problem, not begin a trade war."
Conclusion
The historical record suggests Reagan was fundamentally a free-trade advocate who viewed protectionism as self-destructive. However, as a political pragmatist facing significant domestic pressure and foreign trade challenges, he selectively used protectionist measures—including tariffs—to combat what he saw as "unfair" practices and to leverage better terms for American industries, especially during the 1980s.
Therefore, the claim that he "loved tariffs" is not accurate regarding his core economic philosophy, but it is true that his administration utilized them as a negotiating or retaliatory tool.
Comments